The Soft Market Is the Most Dangerous Time to Put Off Modernisation

·

Andre Symes, Group CEO of Genasys: the soft market is the most dangerous time to put off modernisation

Cheap capacity and falling rates make 'not this year' feel safe. That's exactly why it isn't.

UK commercial insurance rates fell by 8% in the third quarter of 2026, according to the Marsh Global Insurance Market Index.1 That makes eleven consecutive quarters of decline, and the third quarter in a row at the same pace. Property fell 11%, cyber 7% and financial and professional lines 5%, with every major line recording a net average decrease.

For a board weighing a core system replacement, those numbers tend to produce a familiar conversation. Capacity is plentiful, renewals are competitive and the combined ratio still looks healthy, so the programme slides into next year's plan and then the one after that.

The conditions that make deferral comfortable are also the ones in which a replacement is easiest to run well, and the bill for skipping it arrives when they end. Nobody can say reliably when that will be, so the case here is about being ready whenever it happens.

Eleven quarters of falling rates and what they do to the case for change

UK commercial insurance rate changes, third quarter of 2026

-8%
All UK commercial lines, the eleventh quarter of decline in a row
-11%
Property
-7%
Cyber
-5%
Financial and professional lines
Source: Marsh Global Insurance Market Index, Q3 2026.

Marsh's John Donnelly, president of global placement, said buyers worried about geopolitical and economic conditions are keeping their premium savings rather than spending them on broader cover. Capacity was supported by a quiet UK catastrophe season and by incumbent insurers competing hard to retain business, and Insurance Business noted that the absence of major UK losses in the quarter propped up current pricing in a way a more active season would have tested.1

Falling rates also weaken the internal case for change. In a hard market the case for a new system makes itself, because underwriters want new products and the legacy platform's inability to reprice quickly shows up every week. In a soft market the pressure moves to volume and retention, the existing system copes well enough with small rate reductions, and the cost of the old platform sits inside an expense ratio that a strong underwriting year flatters.

Moody's expects that flattering effect to wear off.2 It attributes healthy 2026 P&C earnings to reserve releases, benign weather and cheaper reinsurance, and expects falling prices to start eroding margins from 2027 as those conditions fade. The PRA is also pressing insurers on reserving discipline, which Moody's reads as a sign that reserve releases cannot be relied on indefinitely. A replacement programme judged against 2026 results is being judged against a high-water mark.

Rates are falling faster than claims costs, and the industry has seen this before

Claims costs are not following rates down. Moody's puts UK motor claims inflation in the mid single digits, lower than its post-pandemic peak but still rising,2 while Marsh reports elevated repair and labour costs in motor, with electric vehicles pushing up both severity and repair times.1 The ABI recorded a record £6.1bn of property claims paid in 2025, £1.2bn of which was weather-related.2

Lloyd's chief executive Patrick Tiernan said in the summer that pricing was "coming off faster than we think is rational", and market-wide rates at Lloyd's fell 6.7% in the first half of 2026 against 3.5% in the same period a year earlier.3 Swiss Re's Andreas Berger told the Financial Times the industry had watched this film before and warned that chasing growth in these conditions is dangerous.3

In the version he was referring to, heavy storm losses in 2005 pushed prices up, a quiet 2006 let profits run and pulled in a wave of new entrants, and those entrants competed pricing back down again.3

Fitch moved its outlook for the London Market to deteriorating in late 2025 and reaffirmed it in mid-2026, citing weaker underwriting margins after sustained rate cuts.3 Oxbow Partners forecasts the UK motor combined ratio rising from 89% in 2025 to 95% in 2026 and 96% in 2027, with the record 2025 profit reflecting rate rises taken in 2023 and 2024.34

SignalWhat it showsSource
UK motor claims inflationMid single digits, below its post-pandemic peak but still risingMoody's
UK property claims paid in 2025A record £6.1bn, £1.2bn of it weather-relatedABI
Lloyd's market-wide ratesDown 6.7% in the first half of 2026, against 3.5% a year earlierLloyd's
London Market outlookDeteriorating since late 2025, reaffirmed in mid-2026Fitch
UK motor combined ratio89% in 2025, forecast 95% in 2026 and 96% in 2027Oxbow Partners
Signals that UK insurance rates are falling faster than claims costs

When the market turns, cost to serve decides who survives

When margins compress, the market sets the price, so expense is what an insurer can still control. On a legacy core much of that expense is fixed by the system itself in the form of manual workarounds, rekeying between policy, billing and claims, spreadsheets built to fill reporting gaps and the developer time that every product change consumes.

McKinsey found that insurance cost ratios are 17% higher globally than in 2005, over a period in which telecoms, automotive and airlines brought theirs down.5 The industry has spent two decades digitising without bending that curve, and a large share of the explanation sits in the cost of keeping old systems running alongside new ones.

An insurer that enters a hardening market with a high, fixed cost to serve faces an uncomfortable choice between pricing above competitors to earn the same margin and accepting a thinner margin at the market price. Moody's also flagged that regulatory limits on risk segmentation or pricing flexibility could stop insurers repricing in line with rising claims, which leaves even more of the answer on the expense side.2

What a modern core gives you when the cycle turns

There is plenty of evidence that insurers with modern technology outperform, though most of it is correlational and should be read that way. ACORD's 2026 Insurance Digital Maturity Study of 210 insurers found that the 7% it classes as Digital Competitors delivered a 254% ten-year total shareholder return, against 154% for mid-tier firms, and were the only group to beat average profitability.6 ACORD describes that as an association, and the leaders differ from the rest in many ways beyond their systems.

The operational benefit is better documented. McKinsey's work on IT modernisation in insurance notes that flexible, digitised product systems often bring faster time to market for rate changes and new products.7 BCG estimated in 2024 that a modern core platform can speed up new product time to market by a factor of three to four.8

Speed matters most in the months after a market turns. BCG dates the last hard market in US commercial lines from 2019, and early in any hardening the higher rate goes to the insurers able to charge it.9 An insurer whose rating changes sit in an IT queue for a quarter renews a quarter's worth of business at the old rate, and that money is not recovered later.

Some insurers are already walking away from business

Aviva's UK commercial lines gross written premium fell 4% in the first half of 2026, from £2,008m to £1,927m. Jason Storah, chief executive of Aviva's UK and Ireland general insurance business, told Insurance Times the firm was "not chasing top line" and was walking away from new and renewing business it considered unsustainable.10 He expects soft conditions to last until at least the second half of 2027, and pointed to more capacity, more MGAs and alternative capital chasing returns as the reasons.

Walking away from business is a deliberate underwriting decision, and it depends on knowing, at product, segment and broker level, which business earns its cost of capital. Lloyd's turned away £5.1bn of business in its last financial year, with only around one in five applications reaching managing agents being passed on to Lloyd's.3 Turning away business on that scale depends on good data about which business is worth keeping.

For an insurer or MGA on a legacy platform, the information needed to make that call often arrives weeks after month-end, assembled by hand from systems that disagree with each other. By the time anyone can see which schemes are losing money, another month of them has been written.

A practical test: could you reprice a product in days if the market turned tomorrow?

This exercise needs no forecast, only an honest hour with the people who run your products. Assume your capacity provider or reinsurer wants a 12% rate increase on your largest commercial product, tighter terms on two segments and a new endorsement live within the month, and walk your leadership team through what would happen next.

The repricing test: five questions for your leadership team

1
Who changes the rating tables?
And do they need a developer to do it?
2
How long does testing take?
And is there an environment to test in?
3
Does billing pick up the change automatically?
Or does someone rekey it?
4
Can brokers see the new rates the same day?
On their portals, without waiting for a release.
5
How soon can you report on business written at the new rate?
By segment, while there is still time to act on it.

If the honest answers are measured in months, every renewal in those months will go out at the old rate once the market turns. If they are measured in days, the current system is doing its job and the case for replacement is weaker. Either way, the exercise gives a finance director a figure to work with, which an argument about technology rarely does.

Why the best time to replace a core system is when you don't urgently need to

Core replacements go wrong most often when they are rushed. A programme started in a hard market, under pressure to reprice and launch quickly, carries every incentive to cut corners on data migration and testing and to attempt a big-bang cutover so the benefits arrive sooner. A programme started in a soft market can be sequenced product by product or entity by entity, with the old system running alongside until each piece is proven.

A core replacement started in a hard market and in a soft one

Started in a hard market

  • Pressure to reprice and launch quickly.
  • Corners cut on data migration and testing.
  • A big-bang cutover so the benefits arrive sooner.
  • Teams stretched by renewals that are a scramble for rate.

Started in a soft market

  • Sequenced product by product or entity by entity.
  • The old system runs alongside until each piece is proven.
  • Product experts have time to help configure the new system.
  • Ahead of the queue for specialist talent and vendor capacity.

A soft market also frees up the people a replacement depends on, because underwriting and operations teams have more headroom when renewals aren't a scramble for rate and the experts who understand how the current products really work have time to help configure the new ones. Roland Berger expects the volume of core modernisation programmes to rise sharply over the next five years, creating competition for specialist talent and vendor capacity, so starting before that queue forms has a value of its own.11

This is the approach Genasys is built around. Replacement runs in stages, moving one product or book at a time onto the new platform while the rest stays where it is, and once business is live, product and rating changes are made through configuration by the people who own the products, with no development queue in between.

Show References Hide References
  1. Insurance Business. UK commercial insurance rates fall for eleventh straight quarter.
  2. Insurance Business. Falling prices to squeeze P&C margins from 2027: Moody's.
  3. Insurance Business. Rates are falling faster than claims are: the UK industry knows what happens next.
  4. Insurance Times. Oxbow forecasts profit for motor insurance market.
  5. Risk & Insurance. AI could break insurance's two-decade growth stalemate, McKinsey says.
  6. Insurance Innovation Reporter. ACORD study links digital maturity to insurer outperformance.
  7. McKinsey & Company. IT modernization in insurance: three paths to transformation.
  8. Boston Consulting Group, 2024. Three paths to modernizing core IT for insurers.
  9. Boston Consulting Group, 2025. Are clouds gathering over US property and casualty?
  10. Insurance Times. Aviva refuses to chase unprofitable commercial lines business amid soft market as GWP tumbles 4% in HY results.
  11. Roland Berger. How insurers can maximize value from core insurance system transformation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a soft market a good time to replace a policy administration system?

For most insurers and MGAs it is the best time. Teams have more capacity, there is less pressure to cut corners on migration and testing, and a staged programme can run at a sensible pace. The main risk in a soft market is deferral, because a programme pushed back every year tends to start once the market has already turned.

A replacement started under pressure in a hard market carries every incentive to rush data migration, shorten testing and attempt a big-bang cutover. Started in a soft market, the same programme can move one product, book or entity at a time, with the legacy system running alongside until each stage is proven, and the underwriters and operations staff who know how the current products really work have time to help configure the new ones. On Genasys, products and rating are then changed through configuration by the people who own them, so the next rate change does not wait in a development queue. The Genasys policy administration page explains how this works.

How long have UK commercial insurance rates been falling?

Marsh's Global Insurance Market Index recorded the eleventh consecutive quarterly fall in UK commercial rates in Q3 2026, with composite rates down 8% and property down 11%. Cyber fell 7% and financial and professional lines 5%, and every major line recorded a net average decrease. It was the third quarter in a row at the same pace.

The softening is not limited to the UK company market. Market-wide rates at Lloyd's fell 6.7% in the first half of 2026, against 3.5% in the same period a year earlier, and Lloyd's chief executive Patrick Tiernan said pricing was "coming off faster than we think is rational". Plentiful capacity, a quiet UK catastrophe season and incumbents competing hard to keep business have all kept rates falling, while claims costs in motor and property are still rising.

When will the UK insurance market harden again?

Nobody can say reliably. Aviva's Jason Storah expects soft conditions until at least the second half of 2027 and Moody's expects falling prices to squeeze margins from 2027, but the timing of a turn depends on catastrophe losses, capital flows and claims inflation that no one can forecast with confidence. What an insurer can control is how quickly it could respond.

The signs that a turn is building are already visible: Fitch has rated the London Market outlook as deteriorating since late 2025, and Oxbow Partners forecasts the UK motor combined ratio rising from 89% in 2025 to 95% in 2026 and 96% in 2027. The last cycle followed the same shape, when heavy storm losses in 2005 pushed prices up, a quiet 2006 let profits run and new entrants competed pricing back down. A useful test is to ask how long your own business would take to reprice its largest product, update billing and show brokers the new rates if the market turned tomorrow.

What does cost to serve mean in insurance?

Cost to serve is the total operating cost of administering a policy across its life, from quote and bind through mid-term changes, billing, renewal and claims. On legacy systems a large share of it comes from manual work between disconnected systems, which is why it tends to stay fixed even when premium income falls.

That fixed cost shows up as manual workarounds, rekeying between policy, billing and claims, spreadsheets built to fill reporting gaps and developer time spent on every product change. McKinsey found that insurance cost ratios are 17% higher globally than in 2005. When rates fall and claims costs rise, an insurer with a high cost to serve must either price above competitors or accept a thinner margin, so bringing that cost down is one of the few levers it controls. Running policy, billing and finance and claims on one platform removes the rekeying between them.

What is a staged core system replacement?

A staged replacement moves products, books or legal entities onto the new platform in sequence, rather than switching everything over on a single date. Each stage is tested and proven before the next begins, and the legacy system keeps running for the business that hasn't moved yet, which lowers the risk of any single cutover.

The alternative, a big-bang cutover, moves everything at once and puts the whole book at risk if migration or testing has gaps. Staging lets the business learn from the first product before moving the next, spreads the demand on underwriting and operations teams over time and starts to deliver benefits from the first stage. It suits a soft market well, when there is less pressure to rush. Genasys runs replacements this way, one product or book at a time, and once business is live its product and rating changes are made through configuration by the people who own the products.

Modernise on your terms with Genasys

Genasys replaces core systems in stages, one product or book at a time, and once you are live your own team changes products and rates through configuration, with no development queue. See how policy administration on Genasys works.

Insurers

MGAs

Brokers